A charter school is a public school. Public money comes in the front door. But step around back and you’ll sometimes find a little store: a vendor owned or controlled by the people who run the school, selling it management, curriculum, credentials, payroll or rent. The decision to buy and the payment for the sale sit with the same people.
This School Finance Rock song, a 1950s-style country boogie with a narrator in a miner’s helmet, walks through the five cases in The Charter School Company Store, Revisited.
Newark: the required credential
New teachers at North Star Academy (Uncommon Schools) had to enroll in a Relay Graduate School of Education master’s program as a condition of employment, at roughly $17,500 a year, with salary covering close to half. Relay’s co-founder chaired Uncommon’s board, and both organizations’ IRS filings list the same address: 10 Washington Place.1
Miami: two invoices, one family
Academica-managed schools paid about $9 million a year in management fees and about $19 million a year in rent to Zulueta-family real estate entities, roughly $28 million a year in all. The family’s school properties paid no property tax, and nine schools paid more than a fifth of their revenue in rent.2
Chester, Pennsylvania: we bought it twice
Chester Community Charter School, with about 3,000 K–8 students, paid $60.6 million in public subsidies to its management company, CSMI, since 1999. In 2010, the company’s owner sold buildings he personally owned to the school’s support nonprofit for $50.7 million, financed with Delaware County industrial development authority bonds, and the school leased them back.3
Arizona and New Jersey: all disclosed
About 97% of Arizona charters are exempt from competitive bidding. Crown Charter’s married co-founders directed $111,200 to a nonprofit they lead; Burke Basic leases its building from a company the founding family manages, at $542,000 a year; and Calibre paid $5.3 million in one year to Learning Matters Educational Group. All three appeared in audited statements. In New Jersey, the State Comptroller found in January 2026 that three charter boards had ceded “sweeping authority” to their for-profit manager, CAPS, Inc., which hired and evaluated the executive directors and controlled its own fees, across $57 million in public funds from 2016 to 2023.4
Documenting isn’t stopping
Every one of these arrangements was legal, or close enough to defend, under its state’s disclosure rules. Disclosure makes the store findable; it doesn’t close it. The song ends with ways to close it: keep buyers and sellers from being the same people, keep vendors off the boards (and out of picking them), bid contracts in the open, and open the vendor’s books, not just the school’s. For a fuller reform agenda, see The Company Store Goes to Tallahassee.5
Every line has a receipt
| The lyric | The receipt | Source |
|---|---|---|
| “Seventeen-five a year, your salary covers near half” | Relay tuition about $17,500 a year; salary covered close to half. | Baker (2026) |
| “Both tax forms list the same address, Ten Washington Place” | Uncommon and Relay IRS filings list 10 Washington Place. | Baker (2026) |
| “Nine million in fees, nineteen million in rent” | About $9M management fees + $19M rent ≈ $28M a year. | Baker (2026) |
| “Sixty million to the manager’s company, since ninety-nine” | $60.6M in public subsidies to CSMI since 1999. | Baker (2026) |
| “He sold the school his buildings for fifty million and change” | $50.7M sale financed by county IDA bonds, leased back. | Baker (2026) |
| “Ninety-seven percent don’t have to bid” | About 97% of Arizona charters exempt from competitive bidding. | Baker (2026) |
| “A hundred eleven grand… five-point-three million” | Crown $111,200; Calibre $5.3M to Learning Matters. | Baker (2026) |
| “Found the vendor runnin’ the board… fifty-seven million” | CAPS, Inc. hired and evaluated directors; $57M, 2016–2023. | NJ State Comptroller (2026) |
| “Disclosure makes it findable, but it don’t make it stop” | Each case cleared its state’s disclosure bar. | Baker (2026) |
Key literature
- Baker, B.D. (2026). The Charter School Company Store, Revisited: Five Cases. School Finance 101.
- Baker, B.D. (2026). The Company Store Goes to Tallahassee. School Finance 101.
- Green, P.C., Baker, B.D. & Oluwole, J. (2014). Having it both ways. Emory Law Journal, 63.
- Baker, B.D. & Miron, G. (2015). The Business of Charter Schooling. National Education Policy Center.
More
Companion songs: Follow the Money (If You Can) and We Bought It Twice
More songs: School Finance Rock
Full lyrics: The Company Store (Same Hands on Both Ends)
[Intro]
(spoken)
Now kids, a charter school’s a public school. Public money comes in the front door.
But step around back with me… and you’ll find a little store.
(A store?) A store.
[Verse 1]
Now the board’s a nonprofit, the school’s open to all
But the folks who run the school own a shop down the hall
They sell the management, the curriculum too
The payroll, the back office, the whole caboodle for you
(Who signs the order?) Well, the very same crew!
[Chorus]
It’s the company store (Company store!)
The board says buy and the boss says more
They sign the order and they cash the check
Same hands on both ends (Both ends!) what’d you expect?
It’s all in the audit, it’s all wrote down
Documentin’ ain’t stoppin’ (Ain’t stoppin’!) it just follows it around
[Verse 2]
Up in Newark, son, you got a teachin’ job to keep
But you gotta buy a master’s, and it don’t come cheap
Seventeen-five a year, your salary covers near half
And the network’s board chair helped start that grad school (Ha!) now ain’t that a laugh
Both tax forms list the same address, Ten Washington Place
You buy your credential at the store (At the store?) it’s a job requirement in this case
[Verse 3]
Down in Miami there’s a family with a plan
Runs the management company and owns the land
Nine million in fees (Nine!) nineteen million in rent (Nineteen!)
Two invoices, one family, that’s where the money went
(spoken)
Twenty-eight million a year, kids. Two registers ringin’ in the same store.
[Chorus]
It’s the company store (Company store!)
The board says buy and the boss says more
They sign the order and they cash the check
Same hands on both ends (Both ends!) what’d you expect?
It’s all in the audit, it’s all wrote down
Documentin’ ain’t stoppin’ (Ain’t stoppin’!) it just follows it around
[Verse 4]
Over in Chester, P-A, three thousand kids K through eight
Sixty million to the manager’s company, since ninety-nine, and that’s some freight
Then he sold the school his buildings for fifty million and change
Paid with public bonds, then leased ’em right back (Back?) now ain’t that strange
(spoken)
Folks around there have a name for that.
(What’s it called?) We bought it twice.
[Verse 5]
Out in Arizona, ninety-seven percent don’t have to bid
So a husband and wife sent a hundred eleven grand to the nonprofit they run, yes they did
Another family rents the school its building, owns the landlord too
And a curriculum company gets five-point-three million (Million!) for the whole kit, through and through
Every one of ’em disclosed (Disclosed!) every audit signed and filed
Every one of ’em passed the test (Passed?) now ain’t that wild
[Verse 6]
Then in Jersey, twenty-six, the comptroller took a look
Found the vendor runnin’ the board, writin’ its own book
It hired and graded the directors, set the fees it’d get
Fifty-seven million public dollars (Fifty-seven!) and the store ain’t finished yet
(spoken)
That ain’t a school with a store, kids. That’s a store with a school.
[Bridge]
(spoken)
Now here’s the kicker. Every one of these was legal. Or close enough to defend.
Disclosure makes it findable (Findable!) but it don’t make it stop
You can read the whole receipt (The whole receipt!) and still be buyin’ at the shop
[Verse 7]
So here’s how you close the store, and it ain’t hard to see
Keep the buyer and the seller from bein’ the same family
No board seat for the vendor (No!) no vendor pickin’ the board (No!)
Bid the contracts in the open, show the public what it paid for
Open the vendor’s books as well, not just the school’s own page
‘Cause public money don’t turn private (Don’t turn private!) at the cash register’s cage
[Final Chorus]
Close the company store (Close the store!)
The board says buy, but not from the boss no more
Don’t sign the order and then cash the check
Same hands on both ends (Both ends!) that’s what we’ll correct
It’s all in the audit, it’s all wrote down
Now let’s stop it ‘fore it starts (Stop it!) ‘stead of followin’ it around
[Outro]
(spoken)
Some folks call it a school. Some folks call it a store.
Check who’s standin’ on both sides of the counter.
Write that one down, kids.
- Baker (2026, Sept. 10), The Charter School Company Store, Revisited. I estimate about $6 million flowed from new hires to Relay by 2015; that is my back-of-envelope estimate, not a disclosed figure. ↩︎
- Baker (2026), Revisited. A 2014 federal audit raised related-party concerns; Academica disputed the audit’s characterization. ↩︎
- Baker (2026), Revisited; Pennsylvania Auditor General findings as summarized there. ↩︎
- Baker (2026), Revisited; New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller (Jan. 2026). ↩︎
- Green, P.C., Baker, B.D. & Oluwole, J. (2014). Having it both ways: How charter schools try to obtain funding of public schools and the autonomy of private schools. Emory Law Journal, 63; Baker, B.D. & Miron, G. (2015). The Business of Charter Schooling. NEPC. ↩︎