Investing in people pays. Economists have said so since Adam Smith, measured it since the 1950s, and confirmed it around the world. The United States, though, doesn’t make that investment as one nation. It leaves it to fifty states, and they are pulling apart.
This School Finance Rock song sets the story to Southern soul and gospel, with a narrator in an 18th-century tricorne, from the theory to the global evidence to the divergence I documented in Human Capital Pays, If You Count the Cost.
From Adam Smith to the Mincer equation
In 1776, Adam Smith counted the acquired abilities of a society’s members as part of its fixed capital: the skill a worker learns costs real money and is “a capital fixed and realized, as it were, in his person.”1 In his 1960 presidential address to the American Economic Association, Theodore Schultz argued that what workers know is a form of capital, the product of deliberate investment.2 Gary Becker built the theory of weighing the costs of schooling against its returns, and Jacob Mincer gave economists the earnings equation that estimates the return to one more year of school.3
The global evidence
George Psacharopoulos and Harry Patrinos compiled 1,120 estimates from 139 countries and found a private return of about 9% per extra year of schooling, very stable over decades.4 Skeptics asked whether that is just correlation. Patrinos and Psacharopoulos then gathered 182 estimates from 140 studies in 55 countries comparing ordinary least squares with instrumental-variable (causal) estimates. The causal estimates average 9.7%, about 38% higher than the correlational ones.5
What students learn matters, not just how many years they spend in school. Using global learning data for 164 countries, Angrist, Djankov, Goldberg and Patrinos find human capital accounts for between a fifth and a half of income differences across countries.6
Fifty systems, pulling apart
Most nations make this bet as one country. The U.S. built fifty systems. In my recent work, states with more adequate funding (spending measured against the cost of a common outcome goal) had higher NAEP scores; states with higher scores went on to have more adults with bachelor’s degrees; and states with more degree holders grew faster in income and GDP per capita. Spending adjusted only for wages pointed the wrong way.7 Massachusetts’ GDP per capita was 1.6 times Mississippi’s in 1997 and 2.2 times in 2024. The five most-educated states went from 36% to 46% of adults with a BA between 2009 and 2024; the five least-educated went from 20% to 27%.8
The charts in the video add a state-level look at SFID data: states that funded more adequately in 2019 tended to score higher; a 50-state map of 2023 funding gaps; Massachusetts’ and Mississippi’s adequacy over time; and Mississippi’s funding gaps by district poverty.9
Every line has a receipt
| The lyric | The receipt | Source |
|---|---|---|
| “A capital fixed and realized, as it were, in his person” | Smith counts acquired abilities as fixed capital. | Smith (1776) |
| “Nineteen sixty-one, Theodore Schultz stood tall” | Schultz’s AEA presidential address, published 1961. | Schultz (1961) |
| “Gary Becker wrote the book in sixty-four… Jacob Mincer drew the earnings line” | Human Capital (1964); the Mincer earnings equation. | Becker (1964); Mincer (1958, 1974) |
| “Eleven hundred twenty estimates… a hundred thirty-nine countries… ’bout nine percent” | About 9% private return per year, stable over decades. | Psacharopoulos & Patrinos (2018) |
| “A hundred eighty-two, in fifty-five lands, nine-point-seven percent” | Causal (IV) estimates average 9.7%, about 38% above OLS. | Patrinos & Psacharopoulos (2025) |
| “A fifth to a half of the gap between nations” | Human capital explains one-fifth to one-half of cross-country income differences. | Angrist et al. (2021) |
| “One-point-six to one… two-point-two to one” | Massachusetts vs. Mississippi GDP per capita, 1997 and 2024. | Baker (2026) |
| “Bay State eighth-grade math, five-sixty-one… Alabama four-sixty-six” | 2011 NAEP–TIMSS linking study; Massachusetts behind only 5 of 47 systems. | Baker (2026) |
| “Count the wages but forget the need, and the sign turns wrong” | Wage-adjusted spending predicts −0.31 vs. adequacy +0.39 in the same model. | Baker (2026) |
| “Mississippi’s ninety-three hundred short… twenty-five grand where the poorest families live” | Per-pupil shortfall, 2021–23; $25,100 in the highest-poverty districts. | Baker (2026) |
| “Thirty-six to forty-six… twenty to twenty-seven… the gap grew by three” | Top-5 vs. bottom-5 states, BA share 2009–2024; gap 16 → 19 points. | Baker (2026) |
Key literature
- Becker, G.S. (1964). Human Capital. NBER/Columbia University Press.
- Schultz, T.W. (1961). Investment in human capital. American Economic Review, 51(1), 1–17.
- Mincer, J. (1974). Schooling, Experience, and Earnings. NBER.
- Psacharopoulos, G. & Patrinos, H.A. (2018). Returns to investment in education: A decennial review of the global literature. Education Economics, 26(5).
- Patrinos, H.A. & Psacharopoulos, G. (2025). Causal returns to education. EdWorkingPapers.
- Angrist, N., Djankov, S., Goldberg, P.K. & Patrinos, H.A. (2021). Measuring human capital using global learning data. Nature, 592.
- Hanushek, E.A. & Woessmann, L. (2015). The Knowledge Capital of Nations. MIT Press.
- Baker, B.D. (2026). Human Capital Pays, If You Count the Cost. School Finance 101.
More
Companion songs: Money Matters (The Receipts Rag) and Fundin’ Junction
More songs: School Finance Rock
Full lyrics: Human Capital Pays (If You Count the Cost)
[Intro]
(spoken)
Seventeen seventy-six, kids. A Scotsman named Adam Smith writes that the skill a worker learns costs real money.
He calls it “a capital fixed and realized, as it were, in his person.”
(In his person?) In his person!
[Verse 1]
Back when The Wealth of Nations hit the page
Smith said the training of a hand will earn a wage
You pay to school the mind and train the eye
And it pays you back until the day you die
(Pays you back!) Pays you back!
Nineteen sixty-one, Theodore Schultz stood tall
Told the economists in that convention hall
Workers ain’t just labor, ain’t just hands for hire
What they know is capital (Capital!) the skills they acquire
[Pre-Chorus]
Gary Becker wrote the book in sixty-four
Count the cost, count the return, then count some more
Jacob Mincer drew the earnings line
One more year of schoolin’ (One more year!) watch the paycheck climb
[Chorus]
Human capital pays (If you count the cost!)
Put your money in people and it’s never lost
Every year of learnin’ is a dividend you keep
Human capital pays (Pays!) but it don’t come cheap
(No, it don’t come cheap!)
[Verse 2]
Psacharopoulos and Patrinos went around the world
Eleven hundred twenty estimates unfurled
A hundred thirty-nine countries, near and far
‘Bout nine percent a year (Nine percent!) steady as the northern star
Skeptics said, “Correlation, that’s all you got”
So they rounded up the causal studies, gave it one more shot
A hundred eighty-two, in fifty-five lands
Nine-point-seven percent (Nine-point-seven!) and the return still stands
[Pre-Chorus]
But it ain’t just the years you sit in that chair
It’s what you really learn while you are there (What you learn!)
Angrist, Djankov, Goldberg, Patrinos too
A fifth to a half of the gap between nations comes down to what the people knew
[Chorus]
Human capital pays (If you count the cost!)
Put your money in people and it’s never lost
Every year of learnin’ is a dividend you keep
Human capital pays (Pays!) but it don’t come cheap
(No, it don’t come cheap!)
[Bridge]
(spoken)
Now every nation comes to a fork in the road, kids.
Most of ’em make this choice as one country. One system. One bet on their people.
But the United States? We didn’t build one system.
We built fifty. (Fifty?) Fifty!
Fifty roads, fifty plans, fifty purses to fill
Some states pay the cost (Pay the cost!) and some never will
[Verse 3]
Nineteen ninety-seven, Massachusetts and Mississippi
One-point-six to one in GDP
Twenty twenty-four, take another look
Two-point-two to one (Two-point-two!) it’s written in the book
Bay State eighth-grade math, five-sixty-one
Behind just five of forty-seven systems under the sun
Alabama four-sixty-six, ninety-five points down
Near a whole standard deviation (Whoa!) all the way around
[Verse 4]
Here’s the chain, kids, link by link
Pay what it costs to reach the goal (Scores go up!)
Scores go up (More degrees!)
More degrees (Faster growth!)
Faster growth (And the leaders pull away!)
Count the wages but forget the need
And the sign turns wrong (Wrong way!) it’s a broken lead
Mississippi’s ninety-three hundred short a kid
Twenty-five grand where the poorest families live
Top five states went thirty-six to forty-six with degrees
Bottom five, twenty to twenty-seven (And the gap?) the gap grew by three
[Breakdown]
(spoken)
The states are not converging.
At the top and bottom, they are pulling apart.
(Pulling apart!) Pulling apart.
[Final Chorus]
Human capital pays (If you count the cost!)
Leave it to the fifty and look what gets lost
A nation’s wealth is the learnin’ of its kids
Human capital pays (Pays!) but only where we did
(Only where we did!)
Human capital pays (If you count the cost!)
Put your money in people and it’s never lost
Leaders and laggards on a road divided wide
Human capital pays (Pays!) but it pays on just one side
[Outro]
(spoken)
Fifty systems. Leaders and laggards. That’s the great divergence.
Write that one down, kids.
(Count the cost!)
- Smith, A. (1776). An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Book II, Ch. 1. ↩︎
- Schultz, T.W. (1961). Investment in human capital. American Economic Review, 51(1), 1–17. ↩︎
- Becker, G.S. (1964). Human Capital. NBER/Columbia University Press. Mincer, J. (1958). Investment in human capital and personal income distribution. Journal of Political Economy, 66(4), 281–302; Mincer, J. (1974). Schooling, Experience, and Earnings. NBER. ↩︎
- Psacharopoulos, G. & Patrinos, H.A. (2018). Returns to investment in education: A decennial review of the global literature. Education Economics, 26(5), 445–458. ↩︎
- Patrinos, H.A. & Psacharopoulos, G. (2025). Causal returns to education. EdWorkingPapers. In the video, the correlational bar (about 7%) is implied by the reported 38% gap. ↩︎
- Angrist, N., Djankov, S., Goldberg, P.K. & Patrinos, H.A. (2021). Measuring human capital using global learning data. Nature, 592, 403–408. See also Hanushek, E.A. & Woessmann, L. (2015). The Knowledge Capital of Nations. MIT Press. ↩︎
- Baker, B.D. (2026, Oct. 17). Human Capital Pays, If You Count the Cost. Per SD across states, controlling for 1997 income: adequacy (2009–13) → +2.1 NAEP points (2019); 2003 NAEP → +1.75 points BA share; 2009 BA share → +0.21 points/yr real income growth and +0.43 points/yr GDP per capita growth (1997–2024). Head-to-head: adequacy +0.39 vs. wage-adjusted spending −0.31. Cross-state associations, not causal estimates. Companion paper: Investing in Human Capital: Does Long-Run K-12 Investment Fuel State Economic Growth? ↩︎
- Baker (2026), Human Capital Pays; on slowing convergence, Ganong, P. & Shoag, D. (2017). Why has regional income convergence in the U.S. declined? Journal of Urban Economics, 102, 76–90. ↩︎
- SFID District Cost Database (2026), pupil-weighted state averages. The 2019 scatter includes 45 states with outcome data. The video’s Mississippi quintile chart uses 2023 only; the $25,100 figure in the lyrics covers the highest-poverty districts over 2021–23. ↩︎