Built That Way (Drawn in Red): A School Finance Rock Lesson on Redlining, Housing Discrimination and School Funding


School funding inequality didn’t just happen. It was built, rule by rule and block by block: racial zoning, covenants on deeds, federal home loans for white families only, and maps that shaded Black neighborhoods red. Then the map became the tax base, and the tax base became what the schools could pay.

This School Finance Rock song follows the red ink from a 1939 map to today’s school budgets, with a crooner in a fedora, a big band, and animated maps of metro Kansas City and Hartford.

Built That Way (Drawn in Red) (5:04)

Built, rule by rule

Cities passed racial zoning ordinances in the 1910s until the Supreme Court struck them down in 1917. Racially restrictive covenants took their place on deeds, until the courts stopped enforcing them in 1948. Federal home lending through HOLC, the FHA and the VA went almost entirely to white families, and the HOLC’s 1935–40 maps graded neighborhoods A through D, with D shaded red.1

The man who made the suburbs white

In Kansas City, J.C. Nichols put racial covenants on the properties in his Country Club District; an early billboard advertised “1,000 Acres Restricted.” He went on to national leadership in the real estate industry, and the FHA’s underwriting manual came to recommend covenants for whole subdivisions.2 In 2005, the Kansas City Star found more than 1,200 deeds and documents across the metro still carrying language barring Black families and others.3 In 2020, the city took Nichols’ name off the Plaza fountain and the parkway, and the Urban Land Institute renamed its Nichols Prize.4

First, second and third order effects

First order: the same house is worth less across the line. In Baltimore, Black household income is about 70% of white income and housing values are about 60%. Second order: schools lean on the property tax, so less value means less revenue, and Black residents pay higher effective tax rates for less, a “Black tax.” State aid closes only part of the gap. Third order: concentrated poverty and segregation raise the cost of reaching the same outcomes. In Baltimore City, the cost of national-average outcomes is just over $24,000 per pupil when racial composition is ignored, and $32,214 when it is counted.5

Then and now: Kansas City and Hartford

The maps in the video lay the HOLC grades over today’s school district lines, then add each district’s share of Black and Hispanic students, child poverty, and its funding gap: spending minus the cost of reaching national-average outcomes. In 2023, Kansas City 33 was about $5,600 per pupil short, Hickman Mills about $9,900 short, and Blue Valley about $4,300 ahead. Hartford was about $4,900 short while West Hartford was about $12,400 ahead and Glastonbury about $15,500 ahead.6

Across seven case-study metros, about nine in ten majority Black and Hispanic districts are funded below adequate levels, compared with about one in eight majority-white districts. That’s descriptive, not causal. But it’s one heck of a description.7

If it was built, it can be rebuilt

The song’s blueprint has four parts: rebate the “Black tax” to the homeowners who paid it; send state aid to close the revenue gap the tax base can’t; put race in the aid formula, because the need is real; and audit state formulas for features that keep the gears grinding, like Kansas’s 2005 cap increase for higher-home-value districts.8

Every line has a receipt

The lyricThe receiptSource
“Back in nineteen-ten the city fathers passed a law… the high court struck it down”Racial zoning ordinances in the 1910s; struck down by the Supreme Court in 1917.Shanker (2022)
“Till forty-eight the court said ‘no more’”Racially restrictive covenants became unenforceable in 1948.Shanker (2022)
“Loans to build the American dream… for white folks only”HOLC, FHA and VA lending went almost exclusively to white families.PRRAC (2023)
“A thousand acres restricted, that’s what his billboard said”Nichols advertised his Country Club District as restricted; covenants on its properties barred Black families.Slate (2023); KC Star (2005)
“Twelve hundred deeds still had that language”More than 1,200 documents still carried racial restrictions in 2005.KC Star, Feb. 13, 2005
“In Baltimore the house is worth about sixty cents… the paycheck’s seventy cents”Black housing values about 60% and household income about 70% of white.PRRAC (2023)
“They call it the Black tax”Black residents pay higher effective property tax rates in all seven study metros.PRRAC (2023)
“Twenty-four grand… but thirty-two when you count the rest”Baltimore City cost of national-average outcomes: just over $24,000 ignoring race, $32,214 counting it.PRRAC (2023)
“Nine in ten… one in eight for the white ones”Share of majority Black/Hispanic vs. majority-white districts below adequate funding, seven metros.Shanker (2022)
“Rebate the Black tax… put race right in the formula… audit every formula”Four proposed reforms, including a Kansas example.The Conversation

Key literature

More

Companion songs: Not the Price of Bread and Why Cost Matters

More songs: School Finance Rock

Full lyrics: Built That Way (Drawn in Red)

[Intro]
(spoken)
Pull up a chair, kids. Let me show you a map.
Nineteen thirty-nine. Every neighborhood in town, graded A through D.
And the D’s? (The D’s?)
They colored those in red.

[Verse 1]
Back in nineteen-ten the city fathers passed a law
Tellin’ families where to live; the high court struck it down, but that ain’t all
Then came the covenants, “never sell to them,” written on the deed
Till forty-eight the court said “no more,” but by then they’d planted the seed
Then Uncle Sam stepped in with loans to build the American dream
Thirty years and low money down, for white folks only, so it’d seem
And the maps they drew in thirty-nine, graded A, B, C and D
(What about D?) The D’s got shaded red, kids, where the loans would never be

[Chorus]
It didn’t just happen (No!) it was built that way
Line by line and block by block (Block by block!) it was built that way
Somebody drew the lines in red, and the red is here to stay
‘Cause the map became the tax base (Tax base!)
And the tax base became what the schools could pay
It didn’t just happen, kids, it was built that way!

[Verse 2]
Out in Kansas City there’s a fella you should know
J.C. Nichols built the Country Club District, row on row
“A thousand acres restricted,” that’s what his billboard said
And the deeds kept Black families out, in black ink, not in red
Then he took it on the road to the realtors’ boards and more
Till the FHA put covenants in its rulebook’s core
Twenty-oh-five, the Star went diggin’ through the county files
(What’d they find?) Twelve hundred deeds still had that language, runnin’ miles and miles
(spoken)
They took his name off the fountain in twenty-twenty. The lines are still on the map.

[Verse 3]
Then the blockbusters came knockin’, sellin’ panic door to door
And the agents steered the buyers to the blocks they’d picked before
They zoned the suburbs one-acre lots so the “wrong” folks couldn’t buy
And when the courts said “integrate,” some towns just waved goodbye
(Where’d they go?) They drew a brand-new district line and took the tax base too
(spoken)
Jefferson County, Alabama. Nineteen seventy on. Look it up, kids.

[Verse 4]
Now the first-order effect, kids, you can see it on the street (On the street!)
Same three bedrooms, same front porch, cross the line and the price won’t meet
In Baltimore the house is worth about sixty cents on the dollar
And the paycheck’s seventy cents (Seventy cents?) now ain’t that somethin’ to holler

[Verse 5]
Here’s the second order: the schools run on the property tax
Less value on the block means less revenue comin’ back
So you raise your rate to make it up, you pay more for less, my friend
(What’s that called?) They call it the Black tax, paid every year, and it don’t end
Now the state sends in some aid, sure, it covers part of the gap
But part ain’t whole (Part ain’t whole!) not with a redlined map

[Chorus]
It didn’t just happen (No!) it was built that way
Line by line and block by block (Block by block!) it was built that way
Somebody drew the lines in red, and the red is here to stay
‘Cause the map became the tax base (Tax base!)
And the tax base became what the schools could pay
It didn’t just happen, kids, it was built that way!

[Verse 6]
Now the third order’s the quiet one, it hides in plain sight
Pile up the poverty, wall the kids off, and the cost goes up all right
It takes more to reach the same results, same finish line, same test
In Baltimore it’s twenty-four grand (Twenty-four!) but thirty-two when you count the rest
Less money comin’ in, and more it takes to see ’em through
That’s a squeeze from both directions (Both directions!) and it’s nothin’ new

[Bridge]
Lay the old map over the new one, here’s the score
From Troost Avenue to Hartford, the red lines are funded short of what they’re for
Nine in ten Black and Latino districts underfunded (Nine in ten!)
One in eight for the white ones (One in eight)
(spoken, fast)
Descriptive-not-causal-the-researchers-are-very-careful.
(spoken)
Sure. But that’s one heck of a description.

[Verse 7]
So if it was built, it can be rebuilt, here’s the blueprint, four parts long
Rebate the Black tax to the homeowners who’ve been payin’ all along
Send the state aid in to close the gap the tax base never can
Put race right in the formula, ’cause the need is real (That’s the plan!)
And audit every formula for the gears that keep it grindin’
Like that Kansas cap for high-priced towns (Let’s go find what they’ve been hidin’!)

[Final Chorus]
It didn’t just happen (No!) it was built that way
Line by line and block by block (Block by block!) it was built that way
Somebody drew the lines in red, so we can draw ’em new today
If the map became the tax base (Tax base!)
And the tax base became what the schools could pay
Then we can build it back, kids (Build it back!) build it back a better way!

[Outro]
(spoken)
It didn’t just happen. And it won’t just go away.
Write that one down, kids.

  1. Baker, B.D., Di Carlo, M. & Green, P.C. (2022). Segregation and School Funding. Albert Shanker Institute; and Understanding the first, second, and third order effects on disparities in K-12 funding and outcomes, Poverty & Race (PRRAC), April–July 2023. ↩︎
  2. Mark Dent, “The Man Who Made the Suburbs White,” Slate, Aug. 16, 2023, drawing on Sara Stevens, Developing Expertise. ↩︎
  3. Judy L. Thomas, “‘Curse of Covenant’ Persists,” The Kansas City Star, Feb. 13, 2005, A1. Missouri passed a law that year letting homes associations remove the language. ↩︎
  4. KCUR coverage (2020); Urban Land Institute, “ULI to Rename J.C. Nichols Prize for Visionaries in Urban Development.” ↩︎
  5. Baker, Di Carlo & Green, Poverty & Race (2023). ↩︎
  6. SFID District Cost Database (2026), 2023 values, national outcome standard. HOLC maps: Mapping Inequality (University of Richmond). District boundaries: U.S. Census TIGER 2023. Both metros are shown at the national standard. ↩︎
  7. Baker, Di Carlo & Green (2022), Segregation and School Funding. ↩︎
  8. “How reparations can be paid through school finance reform”, The Conversation. ↩︎

Leave a Reply