Not the Price of Bread: A School Finance Rock Lesson on Costs vs. “Inflation”


“Schools spend more than they used to, even after inflation.” You’ve heard it. It shows up in op-eds, think tank reports and legislative testimony, usually as a chart of per-pupil spending adjusted for the Consumer Price Index, climbing steadily for decades. The implication: schools got more money and didn’t get better, so the money must be going somewhere it shouldn’t.

The question nobody asks is: which inflation? I wrote about this back in 2011, in Understanding Education Costs versus “Inflation”. This time it’s a late-night acoustic jazz trio, in honor of Bob Dorough, who started this whole thing with “Three Is a Magic Number.” The band builds the way the argument does. Upright bass alone for step one, piano for step two, brushes for step three. One, two, three.

Not the Price of Bread (One, Two, Three) (4:41)

One, two, three

One: the price of bread. The CPI-U measures what a typical urban household pays for a basket of goods: food, gas, rent, clothing. Schools don’t buy that basket. They buy people. Salaries and benefits account for about 80 cents of every dollar of current spending in public schools.1 Yet CPI is the default adjustment in most “spending is up, even after inflation” claims, including the federal government’s own summaries.2 For comparing school spending over time, it’s relatively unhelpful. Okay, useless.

Two: the price of pay. A better yardstick prices what schools actually buy. The Employment Cost Index tracks what employers pay for wages and benefits.3 Labor-intensive services like schools face rising costs simply because the wages of educated workers rise with the rest of the economy, and schools have to compete with the hospital and the bank down the street.4 Wages also vary from place to place, which is why comparable wage indices exist.5 But an input price index only prices the ingredients. It assumes the same kids and the same goals.

Three: the cost of the same results. The kids and the goals didn’t stay the same. It costs more to reach the same outcomes with some students than with others: children in poverty, children learning English.6 And we keep raising the bar. The cost of doing more is more, not less. A cost model holds the outcome steady and asks what it takes to get there, given the wages a district must pay, who its students are, and its size and remoteness. That’s what the National Education Cost Model does, for every district in the country.7 Cost isn’t the same as spending. Cost is the minimum spending needed to reach a given level of outcomes, for these kids, in this place.8

The shaded part

Here’s why this matters for state policy. Many state school funding formulas, when they adjust at all, adjust by the CPI or something like it. Year after year, a formula indexed to bread and gas falls further behind what it actually costs to reach the state’s own goals with the state’s own kids. Then the press release says funding “kept up with inflation.” Kept up with what? With the bread. Not the kids. “Flat in real dollars” sounds steady, but steady can still come up short, and the gap compounds. That shaded part between the lines is a classroom. It’s the nurse, the band, the support.

Not one. Not merely two. School funding formulas have to keep up with three: the cost of constant outcomes.

Every line has a receipt

The graphs in the video are stylized illustrations of the concept, not actual data. Ms. Rivera in room ten is a stand-in for every teacher a district has to recruit and keep.

The lyricThe receiptSource
“Somebody said schools spend more than they used to… even after inflation. Which inflation, baby?”The standard claim adjusts per-pupil spending by the CPI. The adjustment is the question.NCES (2010); Baker (2011)
“They took the CPI, the shopper’s basket… a loaf of bread, a gallon of gas, a pair of jeans”The CPI-U tracks prices of goods and services bought by urban consumers.BLS CPI
“A school don’t buy a gallon… it runs on teachers, aides and nurses… most every dollar walks in on two feet”About 80 percent of current spending goes to salaries and benefits.NCES Fast Facts
“Wages, benefits, the Employment Cost Index, watch it rise”The ECI tracks employer costs for wages and benefits.BLS ECI
“When the hospital down the street raises what it pays, Ms. Rivera in room ten needs that too, or she won’t stay”Schools compete with other employers for educated workers; teacher pay has to stay competitive with non-teacher pay.Baker (2011); Baumol (1967)
“It prices the ingredients, it don’t say who gets fed”Input price indices measure the price of resources, not the cost of outcomes.Baker (2024)
“More kids learning English, more families stretched thin”It costs more to achieve the same outcomes with some students than with others.Duncombe & Yinger (2005); Baker (2011)
“And we raised the bar… you can’t raise the bar for free”“The cost of doing more is more, not less.”Baker (2011)
“So the National Education Cost Model asks it right: what would it take for the same results?”The NECM estimates per-pupil costs of reaching national average outcomes for every district, accounting for wages, student needs and district characteristics.Baker, Weber & Srikanth (2021)
“That line climbs the fastest, and it isn’t fat or waste”Cost is the minimum spending needed for a given level of outcomes. Spending above cost is inefficiency; cost itself is not.Baker (2024)
“‘Funding kept up with inflation!’ Kept up with what? With the bread, honey. Not the kids.”States have often held spending flat or cut it even as costs rose.Baker (2011)

Key literature

Read the full case

Understanding Education Costs versus “Inflation” (Jan. 12, 2011)

Defining Productivity, Cost, and Efficiency (Nov. 25, 2024)

Why Cost Matters: A School Finance Blues (With Receipts) (Nov. 10, 2026)

More songs: School Finance Rock

Full lyrics: Not the Price of Bread (One, Two, Three)

[Intro]
Somebody said schools spend more than they used to…
even after inflation.
Mm. Which inflation, baby?

[Verse 1]
They took the CPI, the shopper’s basket, cart and all,
A loaf of bread, a gallon of gas, a pair of jeans down at the mall.
Said, “If schools went up much faster than the price of milk and rye,
Then those schools are spending too much, and we oughta wonder why.”
But a school don’t buy a gallon, and it don’t run on rye,
It runs on teachers, aides and nurses, and the bus driver waving hi.
Most every dollar walks in on two feet, every day,
So pricing schools like groceries? That just ain’t the way.

[Chorus]
One! (One!) That’s the price of bread,
Makes no sense for a school, like I said.
Two! (Two!) That’s the price of pay,
Better, but it’s only half the way.
Three! (Three!) What it costs to get the kids where they need to be.
Not one, not only two,
The formula’s gotta keep up with three.

[Verse 2]
So let’s price the things a school actually buys,
Wages, benefits, the Employment Cost Index, watch it rise.
When the hospital down the street raises what it pays,
Ms. Rivera in room ten needs that too, or she won’t stay.
Now that line climbs steeper, that’s an honest step ahead,
But it prices the ingredients, it don’t say who gets fed.
Same teachers, same class sizes, at this year’s going rate,
But are they the same kids? Same finish line?
(Wait!)

[Verse 3]
More kids learning English, more families stretched thin,
More kids who need more help to get where the others have been.
And we raised the bar, “every kid ready,” yes we did,
But you can’t raise the bar for free and just hope for every kid.
Same ingredients, same prices, but a bigger crowd to feed,
And the recipe got fancier. So here’s the question we need:
Not “What do the groceries cost?” No, no, no,
“What’s it cost to get them there?” That’s the way to go.

[Chorus]

[Verse 4]
So the National Education Cost Model asks it right:
“What would it take for the same results, for the kids who walk in tonight?”
It counts the wages that a district has to pay,
The kids in poverty, the kids learning English every day,
How big the district is, how far the buses roam,
Hold the outcome steady, then add up what it takes to get ’em home.
That line climbs the fastest, and it isn’t fat or waste,
It’s the price of the same good job when the job got harder to face.

[Bridge]
Now see that shaded part between the lines?
Tie your formula to bread and gas, and every year it falls behind,
A little further back, a little further, a little more.
Then the headline says “Funding kept up with inflation!”
(Kept up with what?)
With the bread, honey. Not the kids.
“Flat in real dollars” sounds steady, but steady can still come up short.
That shaded part’s a classroom. That’s the nurse, the band, the support.

[Final Chorus]
One! (One!) That’s the price of bread,
Fine for the grocery, but for schools, it’s the wrong road ahead.
Two! (Two!) That’s the price of pay,
Better, but it’s only half the way.
Three! (Three!) What it costs to get the kids where they need to be.
Not one, not merely two,
If you want the kids to make it through,
The formula’s gotta keep up with three.

[Outro]
(One… two…) Three.
Write that one down, kids.

  1. National Center for Education Statistics, Fast Facts: Expenditures. From 2010–11 to 2019–20, 80 percent of current expenditures went to salaries and benefits every year. ↩︎
  2. For example, NCES, Revenues and Expenditures for Public Elementary and Secondary Education: Fiscal Year 2008: “Adjusting for inflation, current expenditures per pupil have grown 32 percent since FY 95 … and 60 percent since FY 85.” ↩︎
  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index and Employment Cost Index. The ECI tracks changes in employers’ costs for wages and benefits, and BLS publishes series for state and local government workers, including those in education. ↩︎
  4. Baumol, W.J. (1967). Macroeconomics of unbalanced growth: The anatomy of urban crisis. American Economic Review, 57(3), 415–426. In labor-intensive services, costs rise faster than prices in general because wages have to keep pace with the rest of the economy. ↩︎
  5. Taylor, L.L. & Fowler, W.J. (2006). A comparable wage approach to geographic cost adjustment (NCES 2006-321). National Center for Education Statistics. ↩︎
  6. Duncombe, W. & Yinger, J. (2005). How much more does a disadvantaged student cost? Economics of Education Review, 24(5), 513–532. See also Baker (2011), Understanding education costs versus “inflation”: “the cost of doing more is more, not less.” ↩︎
  7. Baker, B.D., Weber, M. & Srikanth, A. (2021). Informing federal school finance policy with empirical evidence. Journal of Education Finance, 47(1), 1–25. The model estimates per-pupil costs of reaching national average outcomes in reading and math, grades 3–8, for every district. District estimates are available through the School Finance Indicators Database. ↩︎
  8. Baker (2024), Defining productivity, cost, and efficiency. Cost is the minimum spending needed to reach a given level of outcomes, given student backgrounds and contextual factors; spending minus inefficiency equals cost. ↩︎

Leave a Reply