Schools Are Not Socks: A School Finance Rock Lesson on “Money Follows the Child”


“The money belongs to the child, not the system.” It’s the line voucher and charter advocates reach for first: put each kid’s share of school funding in a backpack, let it follow the child wherever the family chooses, and let the schools compete for it. It sounds like fairness. It isn’t how public money, or public schools, actually work.

I’ve taken this on in tweets (2017), in a school finance primer (2017) and in Seussical verse (2026). This time it’s a 1970s Saturday-morning civics lesson: a carnival pitchman selling backpacks full of cash, your professor at the chalkboard and a chorus of pencils asking the obvious question. Whose money is it?

Schools Are Not Socks: a School Finance Rock lesson (4:43)

Every line has a receipt

The arguments in the song come from three of my posts: Oh, the Thinks You Can Think About School Funds (2026), Public Goods & the “Money Belongs to the Child” Fallacy (in Tweets) (2017) and School Finance Prerequisites: On the Provision of Public Education (2017). A few things are invented for the cartoon, and the video labels them: the “twelve grand” in the pitch is an illustrative round number, not a statistic; Uncle Zed and the lady at the bakery are stand-ins for every neighbor who pays; and Acme Charter is fictional.

The lyricThe receiptSource
“Your child’s school dollars, packed in a handy little backpack… the money follows the child!”The claim under review: school dollars “belong to the child, not the system.” It assumes a simple, straight line from tax collection to spending and purely individual benefits.Baker (2017a); Baker (2017b)
“Now the system’s just a faceless, gray bureaucracy, but your kid’s a shining star”The argument casts government institutions as faceless and bad and children as good, even though those institutions exist to serve children.Baker (2017b)
“Kid, it’s yours the way the sidewalk’s yours. You just can’t take it home.”Assets bought with public money don’t belong only to the parents and students using them this year.Baker (2017a)
“The lady at the bakery… the couple on the fourth floor… Uncle Zed, whose kids are forty, paying every year”Tax dollars are pooled by society to serve the public interest. Contributors include residents with no children in school, and they benefit too.Baker (2026); Baker (2017a)
“That’s capitalization, kids! Good schools make the whole town nice!”Strong public schools are capitalized into home values, so homeowners benefit whether or not they have kids in school.Baker (2017b); Black (1999)
“So we pool it up together, and we govern it out loud”Public dollars are controlled by the democratically governed community under the law, not by individual families.Baker (2017b)
“Schools are not socks… it’s a promise that a whole town made”Public goods aren’t private purchases; they take joint planning, especially through hard times. Schools are promises communities made.Baker (2026)
“Does the boiler run one kid cooler? Does the roof skip one kid’s crash? Does the bus route skip a corner?”When one child leaves, the building still needs heat and the bus still runs its route. Costs don’t shrink with each departing student, so revenue that leaves with the child opens a hole.Baker (2026); Bifulco & Reback (2014); Ladd & Singleton (2020)
“Spread the cost across the whole town, and the cost per kid goes down. Split the kids up, costs stay put”“Money follows the child” ignores marginal costs and economies of scale, which are core reasons public institutions exist.Baker (2017b); Andrews, Duncombe & Yinger (2002)
“Twenty-year bonds on the gym roof and the science-lab bill… built for kids not born yet”Buildings and operations are often financed with 15- to 20-year debt, and the assets serve future generations, not only current users. Taxpayers keep paying after their own kids are grown.Baker (2017b); Baker (2026)
“So the money ‘belongs to the child’? Kid… which child? Every one!”Public money matters not only to those using it here and now.Baker (2017a)
“Fire department? Here’s your voucher! Police? Here’s a refund! National defense? …and you’re on your own!”The reductio: apply “the money belongs to the citizen” to public safety (buy your own fence), fire protection (buy your own hose, or “charter” fire departments) and national defense (“Here’s your voucher – you’re on your own?”).Baker (2017a)
“Let’s take a vote of parents! Fifty-one percent, hooray! Hand the school to Acme Charter”Parent-trigger laws let a simple majority of a school’s current parents hand it, capital assets included, to a private manager. That authority shouldn’t rest with this year’s parents when the whole taxpaying public financed the school. (Acme Charter is fictional.)Baker (2017b), fn. iii
“Confronting all that tension, kids, is how a town gets right”Public institutions create friction among their constituents. “Confronting (not avoiding) tensions is net + for society!”Baker (2017a)
“Technically, education is a quasi-public good… Fair enough. Parks are quasi too.”An economist’s fair correction to the original thread: schooling isn’t a pure public good. “Quasi-public good,” like roads, is the better term. The argument doesn’t depend on it.Baker (2017a), footnote
“We invest public resources into the education of the public, for the benefit of the public.”Quoted directly.Baker (2017b)

Why the money can’t just follow the child

It was never the child’s money. Taxes are pooled to buy things that serve the public interest, things no household could buy alone.1 That’s true of K–12 schooling even though it isn’t a textbook “pure” public good. It’s worth noting where the voucher idea started. Milton Friedman’s 1955 essay accepted both the public interest in education and public financing of it. What he disputed was that government had to run the schools. The question has always been whether education is mainly a public good or a private one, and what follows from each answer.2

Everyone chips in, and everyone benefits. Neighbors with no kids in school pay for the schools, and they get something back: an educated public, and home values that rise with school quality. When economists compare houses on either side of an attendance-zone boundary, parents pay about 2.5% more for a 5% increase in test scores.3

When the money leaves, the costs stay. Running two systems of public schools under separate governance can create excess costs, and how states finance charters decides who absorbs them.4 In North Carolina, Ladd and Singleton found a negative fiscal impact of more than $500 for each student left in one urban district, or about $3,600 for each student who enrolled in a charter. In Michigan, Arsen and Ni found that charter competition clearly put districts under fiscal stress, without spurring them to shift resources toward instruction. The reason is the one in the song. Spreading fixed costs across a whole community is why cost per pupil falls as systems grow. Splitting the kids up raises costs per pupil, and the effect is sharpest for small districts.5

And the economists are right, sort of. Schooling is rival and excludable, so it’s a quasi-public good, like roads and parks.6 None of that turns a public school system into an annual subsidy for this year’s enrollees. Nobody’s getting a voucher for their own personal swing.

Key literature

Read the full case

Oh, the Thinks You Can Think About School Funds: Seussical Thoughts on Money Follows the Child (May 8, 2026)

Public Goods & the “Money Belongs to the Child” Fallacy (in Tweets) (Mar. 28, 2017)

School Finance Prerequisites: On the Provision of Public Education (Sept. 11, 2017)

More songs: School Finance Rock

Full lyrics: Schools Are Not Socks

[Intro]
(Pitchman) Step right up, folks! Today only! Your child’s school dollars, packed in a handy little backpack! Take ’em anywhere you like! Because the money… follows… the child!
(Narrator) Hold on there, mister. Whose money is it?

[Verse 1: Pitchman]
Now the system’s just a faceless, gray bureaucracy,
But your kid’s a shining star, so set those dollars free!
There’s twelve grand with her name on it, it’s hers to take and spend,
Just zip it in her lunchbox and go shopping, little friend!
(Is it really in my name?)
Why, sure, it’s practically your own!
(Narrator) Kid, it’s yours the way the sidewalk’s yours. You just can’t take it home.

[Verse 2: Narrator]
So who put in those dollars? Let’s go knocking door to door:
There’s the lady at the bakery, and the couple on the fourth floor,
There’s your Uncle Zed, whose kids are forty, paying every year
For a school he’ll never visit, and he’s glad to have it here.
’Cause when the schools are good, the houses on the block go up in price.
That’s capitalization, kids! (Capi-what?) Good schools make the whole town nice.
So we pool it up together, and we govern it out loud:
Public money for the public, by the public, for the crowd.

[Chorus]
Schools are not socks! (Not socks!)
You can’t just pull one off the rack.
Schools are not socks! (Not socks!)
And there ain’t no money-back.
That money never followed you, it was never yours alone.
It’s a promise that a whole town made, so no kid walks alone.

[Verse 3: Narrator]
Say one kid leaves the building with a backpack full of cash.
Does the boiler run one kid cooler? Does the roof skip one kid’s crash?
Does the bus route skip a corner? Does the hallway dim one light?
Third grade still needs a teacher, and the heat’s still on all night.
Take a kid from every classroom, and the costs just barely drop,
But the dollars walked right out the door. So now… where do we chop?
(The art room?) Yep. (The nurse?) Uh-huh. (Not the BAND?!) You’re catching on.
Spread the cost across the whole town, and the cost per kid goes down.
Split the kids up, costs stay put, and the system wobbles round and round.

[Verse 4: Narrator]
And that school your mama went to? Why, we’re paying for it still.
Twenty-year bonds on the gym roof and the science-lab bill.
It was built for kids not born yet, it’ll stand for kids to come,
So the money “belongs to the child”? Kid… which child? (Every one!)

[Chorus]

[Bridge]
(Pitchman) Hey, if it works for schools, then let’s try it with the rest!
Fire department? Here’s your voucher! Buy a hose, you know best!
Police? Here’s a refund! Go and build yourself a fence!
National defense? Here’s your voucher…
(Narrator) …and you’re on your own. Makes no sense!
Some things we buy together ’cause alone we never could.
That’s what the taxes are for, kids: building what’s too big for one neighborhood.

[Verse 5]
(Pitchman) Then let’s take a vote of parents! Fifty-one percent, hooray!
Hand the school to Acme Charter: gym and buses, all, today!
(Narrator) Now hold it, friend, this building’s owned by every taxpayer in town,
Not this year’s PTA to sign away or tear it down.
It’s democratic, sure it’s messy, and we argue and we fight,
But confronting all that tension, kids, is how a town gets right.

[Footnote, spoken fast]
“Technically-education-is-a-quasi-public-good-not-a-pure-public-good-it’s-rival-and-excludable-the-economists-would-like-a-word.”
Fair enough. Parks are quasi too. Nobody’s getting a voucher for their own personal swing.

[Final Chorus]
Schools are not socks! (Not socks!)
And a town is not a store.
Schools are not socks! (Not socks!)
You can’t take the school out the door.
That money never followed you, it was never yours alone.
It’s a promise that a whole town made, so no kid walks alone.
(Which child?) Every child! (Whose money?) Everyone’s!
It’s a promise that a whole town made… and we keep it till it’s done.

[Outro]
“We invest public resources into the education of the public, for the benefit of the public.” Write that one down, kids.
(Pitchman, fading) …Backpacks! Get your backpacks… Swings! Get your swings! Personal swings…

  1. Samuelson, P.A. (1954). The pure theory of public expenditure. Review of Economics and Statistics, 36(4), 387–389. The foundational statement of what economists mean by a public good. ↩︎
  2. Friedman, M. (1955). The role of government in education. In R. Solo (Ed.), Economics and the Public Interest. Friedman accepted the public interest in education and even public financing; his argument was that government need not run the schools. See also Levin, H.M. (1999). The public-private nexus in education. American Behavioral Scientist, 43(1), 124–137; and Labaree, D.F. (1997). Public goods, private goods: The American struggle over educational goals. American Educational Research Journal, 34(1), 39–81. ↩︎
  3. Black, S.E. (1999). Do better schools matter? Parental valuation of elementary education. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114(2), 577–599. Comparing houses on either side of attendance-zone boundaries, parents paid about 2.5% more for a 5% increase in test scores. ↩︎
  4. Bifulco, R. & Reback, R. (2014). Fiscal impacts of charter schools: Lessons from New York. Education Finance and Policy, 9(1), 86–107 (Albany and Buffalo). Ladd, H.F. & Singleton, J.D. (2020). The fiscal externalities of charter schools: Evidence from North Carolina. Education Finance and Policy, 15(1), 191–208. Arsen, D. & Ni, Y. (2012). The effects of charter school competition on school district resource allocation. Educational Administration Quarterly, 48(1), 3–38. ↩︎
  5. Andrews, M., Duncombe, W. & Yinger, J. (2002). Revisiting economies of size in American education: Are we any closer to a consensus? Economics of Education Review, 21(3), 245–262. ↩︎
  6. Baker (2017), Public goods & the “money belongs to the child” fallacy (in tweets), footnote. Public schooling isn’t a pure public good in the economist’s sense (non-rival and non-excludable); “quasi-public good,” like roads, is the better term. See also School finance prerequisites (2017), footnote ii. ↩︎

Leave a Reply