Everybody loves parfaits, and everybody hates property taxes. That’s how I opened On Parfaits & Property Taxes back in 2012. This School Finance Rock song takes the parfait literally: school funding comes in layers, local on the bottom, state in the middle, and a sprinkle of federal on top. Money matters, but where the money comes from matters too.
The sound is 1950s soda-shop doo-wop, with a narrator in a soda jerk’s paper cap.
The layers
Nationally, about 45% of K-12 revenue comes from local sources, about 47% from the state and about 8% from the federal government. A century ago, local sources supplied more than 80%.1 The mix varies enormously by state, from roughly 30% state funding to about 90%.2
The bottom layer is the steadiest
The property tax is the most stable layer. Income taxes swing the most in a recession and sales taxes dip when shoppers stop buying; property tax revenue has held up since the early 1980s and acts as a stabilizer. But local money stays home: a rich town’s layer is tall and a poor town’s is short, and a $2 million house can carry a lower effective tax rate than a $200,000 house in Newark.3
Fairer but shakier
State revenue is the great equalizer. Across states, heavier reliance on state revenue goes with more equitable funding, and within states a rising state share goes with more adequate funding. The catch: state revenue, built on income and sales taxes, is more volatile year to year.4 And it isn’t just the layer, it’s the recipe. New Jersey leans heavily on property taxes and funds relatively fairly; North Carolina leans less on them and is still inequitable. The formula goes through the political meat-grinder, and New York’s STAR property-tax relief sends more per year to richer communities than poorer ones.5
The recipe
Keep a balanced glass, with a third or more from local sources. Don’t scrape out the bottom layer. Consider state taxation of commercial and industrial property, which could shift as much as a fifth of K-12 funding from inequitably to equitably distributed revenue, and broaden the sales tax base without tipping it onto the poor. Then build a fair formula: that’s what the layers are for.6
Every line has a receipt
| The lyric | The receipt | Source |
|---|---|---|
| “Everybody loves parfaits! And everybody hates property taxes.” | The opening line of the 2012 post. | Baker (2012) |
| “Local on the bottom, and the state fills the cup… just ten percent” | Roughly 45% local, 45% state, 10% federal. | The Source Code; NCES |
| “Steady as a rock when the economy cracks” | Property tax revenue is less volatile than income or sales tax revenue. | Baker (2012) |
| “A two-million-dollar house… its rate can be lower than a little house in Newark” | A $2M NY/NJ home may pay over $30,000 yet face a lower effective rate than a $200,000 home in Newark or Utica. | Baker (2012) |
| “The great equalizer! That’s what the study found” | “State revenue is the great equalizer in school finance.” | The Source Code |
| “Fairer but shakier, steady but unfair” | Higher state shares: more equitable, more volatile. | The Source Code |
| “New Jersey leans on property, but it’s fairer… North Carolina… still ain’t passed the test” | State share isn’t related to overall funding fairness. | Baker (2012) |
| “New York’s STAR tax relief gives the most to the wealthy towns” | STAR spends more per year on richer communities than poorer ones. | Baker (2012) |
| “A third or more from local… tax the factories… a fifth of school money” | Keep about a third or more local; state tax on commercial/industrial property could shift up to 20%. | The Source Code |
Key literature
- Baker, B.D., Di Carlo, M. & Oberfield, Z.W. (2023). The Source Code. Albert Shanker Institute.
- Baker, B.D. (2012). Friday Finance 101: On Parfaits & Property Taxes. School Finance 101.
- National Center for Education Statistics. Digest of Education Statistics 2022, Tables 235.10 and 235.20.
More
Companion songs: Cost Minus Capacity and Cost-Based State of Mind
More songs: School Finance Rock
Full lyrics: Layer It Up (The Source Code)
[Intro]
(spoken, female)
Everybody loves parfaits!
(spoken, male)
And everybody hates property taxes.
(Bom, bom, shoo-bop!)
[Verse 1]
Down at the soda shop I ordered up a treat
A tall glass of layers, oh so cool and sweet
The soda jerk leaned over, said, “Kids, you know what’s in that cup?
It’s the way we pay for schools, so let me build it up”
(Build it up!)
[Chorus]
Layer it up (Layer it up!) layer it up (Layer it up!)
Local on the bottom, and the state fills the cup
A sprinkle of federal right on the top (Just ten percent!)
Money matters, baby, that much is true
But where the money comes from (Comes from!) matters too!
[Verse 2]
The bottom layer’s local, it’s the property tax
Steady as a rock when the economy cracks
Income tax goes up and down like a yo-yo on a string
Sales tax dips when the shoppers quit, but property tax just keeps its swing
(Steady!) But local money stays at home, it never leaves its town
So the rich town’s layer’s tall (Tall!) and the poor town’s layer’s down (Down)
[Pre-Chorus]
(spoken)
And here’s a funny thing, kids. A two-million-dollar house might pay thirty thousand a year in taxes…
but its rate can be lower than a little house in Newark. (No way!) Way.
[Verse 3]
The middle layer’s state, it comes from income and from sales
It can reach across the county line where the local layer fails
(The great equalizer!) That’s what the study found
States that lean on the state layer spread the money fairer ’round
And when a state’s share goes up over time, the funding gets more adequate too
But here’s the catch, oh sugar (The catch?) here’s the catch for you
[Bridge]
The more you lean on the state, the more it shakes (Shake, shake!)
Boom-time feast and a bust-time ache
Fairer but shakier (Fairer but shakier!)
Steady but unfair (Steady but unfair)
Crack the code, kids (Crack the code!)
Find the balance there
[Chorus]
Layer it up (Layer it up!) layer it up (Layer it up!)
Local on the bottom, and the state fills the cup
A sprinkle of federal right on the top (Just ten percent!)
Money matters, baby, that much is true
But where the money comes from (Comes from!) matters too!
[Verse 4]
Now New Jersey leans on property, but it’s fairer than the rest
North Carolina leans on the state, and it still ain’t passed the test
So it ain’t just the layer, kids, it’s the recipe (The recipe!)
The formula goes through the political meat-grinder, that’s where it’s decided, see
And New York’s STAR tax relief (Relief!) gives the most to the wealthy towns
Don’t call that fair, honey, that’s turned upside down
[Verse 5]
So here’s the recipe, keep it balanced in the glass
A third or more from local (A third!) don’t you scrape it out too fast
Let the state tax the factories and the office parks downtown
That could move a fifth of school money to where it’s shared around
Widen up the sales tax base, but don’t tip it on the poor
Then build a formula that’s fair (Fair!) that’s what the layers are for
[Final Chorus]
Layer it up (Layer it up!) layer it up (Layer it up!)
Don’t scrape off the bottom, and let the state fill the cup
A sprinkle of federal right on the top (Just ten percent!)
Money matters, baby, that much is true
But where the money comes from (Comes from!) matters too!
[Outro]
(spoken, male)
So, still hate property taxes?
(spoken, female)
Pass me a spoon.
(spoken, male)
Write that one down, kids.
(Bom, bom, shoo-bop!)
- National Center for Education Statistics, Digest of Education Statistics 2022, Table 235.10 (2019–20 shares: local 44.9%, state 47.5%, federal 7.6%; 1919–20: local 83.2%). Baker, Di Carlo & Oberfield, The Source Code, describe the split as roughly 45/45/10. ↩︎
- NCES, Digest Table 235.20 (2019–20). ↩︎
- Baker (2012), On Parfaits & Property Taxes, using Rockefeller Institute data. The volatility chart in the video is a stylized illustration, not actual data. ↩︎
- Baker, B.D., Di Carlo, M. & Oberfield, Z.W. (2023). The Source Code: Revenue Composition and the Adequacy, Equity, and Stability of K-12 School Spending. Albert Shanker Institute. ↩︎
- Baker (2012), On Parfaits & Property Taxes. ↩︎
- Recommendations from Baker, Di Carlo & Oberfield (2023), The Source Code. ↩︎