Cost-Based State of Mind: A School Finance Rock Lesson on New York’s Foundation Aid at 20


New York’s Foundation Aid formula turns 20 next year, and it was never built on a real estimate of what it costs to give every child an equal shot. So the newest School Finance Rock song takes a drive from Plattsburgh to Montauk, Salamanca to the Sound, and sings the receipts.

It comes in two versions. The first is a late-night New York piano ballad. The second, the Empire Remix, keeps the piano-ballad verses and hands the numbers to a rapper over boom-bap drums, with a big R&B hook: I’m in a cost-based state of mind.

The song makes two points. First, fix the original errors in the 2007 formula. Second, and more important, build an entirely new formula from sound empirical cost analysis, not from an average of districts that already made it.

Cost-Based State of Mind (Empire Remix) (5:12)
Cost-Based State of Mind (Piano Ballad) (6:23)

In both videos I walk the state with the receipts in hand: Albany, the Walkway Over the Hudson in Poughkeepsie, Plattsburgh Bay, Montauk Point, the Finger Lakes, the Hudson Highlands, Lake Champlain, Watkins Glen, Niagara Falls and Whiteface Mountain. The remix adds animated charts for the formula, the base, the 57 small city districts and the need weights.

The brief and the deck

Every number in the song comes from my new policy brief and slide deck for the New York State Association of Small City School Districts (NYSCS).

Every line has a receipt

The lyricWhat it meansSource
“Base times need times region, count the kids and multiply”Foundation Aid = base × Pupil Need Index × Regional Cost Index × pupil count (TAFPU), adopted in 2007 after CFE.2026 brief
“The base was only teachin’ spend, they cut out special ed / Left the buses and the lights out”The base counts general-education instructional spending only. Special ed is subtracted, and transportation, utilities and operations are left out.2026 brief
“Took the ‘successful’ districts, then they dropped the pricey half”The base averages the lower-spending half of districts meeting the state’s outcome bar.2026 brief; 2013 post
“Base is forty percent… the other sixty’s multipliers no one tested”The base is 40–42% of sound basic funding. The need and regional multipliers behind the rest have little or no empirical basis.2026 brief
“Every spring a price index, whichever one’ll close the deal”The base is updated each year by an inflation index chosen in budget negotiations, not by re-estimating costs.2026 brief
“Eighty-five hundred for the base in twenty-seven… ten to thirteen grand a kid”The FY 2027 base is $8,496. Recalculated by the formula’s own method, it would be $10,229–$13,190.2026 brief, Table 1
“Small cities seven grand behind… Poughkeepsie down eleven”By 2027 small city districts fall more than $7,000 per pupil short of the formula’s own target. Poughkeepsie is about $11,000 short.2026 brief
“Forty-five of fifty-seven… fifty-six of fifty-seven”45 of 57 small cities spend below the cost of state-average outcomes, and 56 of 57 below the cost of a higher standard. 27 are short by more than $15,000 per pupil.2026 deck (cost models)
“Eighty-five cents on the dollar… sixty-two to reach for more”On average, small cities spend 85% of the cost of average outcomes and 62% of the cost of the higher standard.2026 deck (cost models)
“Utica’s down twenty thousand every kid”Utica’s gap exceeds $20,000 per pupil.2026 deck (cost models)
“Point-one-two for kids with no home… English learners up seven points”FY 2027 added a 0.12 weight for homeless and foster-care students and raised the ELL weight from 0.53 to 0.60. The cost model says the homeless and foster weights should be much larger.2026 brief
“Raise the base, raise the weights, and push ’em up toward one”The short-term fix: raise the base at least 10.75% over the inflation-adjusted base, and move need weights toward 1.0.2025 report; 2026 deck

Why a “successful schools” average can’t price success for all

The bridge of the song is the line I care most about: a “successful schools” average is no measure at all of what it costs to bring success to all of you.

A successful schools analysis looks at districts that already hit the bar and averages what they spend. Those districts are mostly low-poverty, low-need places, and New York then kept only the cheaper half of them. That tells you what success costs for children who were already likely to succeed. It tells you nothing about what it costs for children in Utica, Poughkeepsie or Mount Vernon to reach the same outcomes.

The state then tries to bolt that missing cost back on with need and regional multipliers that were never estimated from data. Cost modeling does the job directly. It estimates how the spending needed to reach a given outcome changes with student poverty, English learners, wages, scale and sparsity, school by school and district by district. In New York, that cost rises with poverty much more steeply than spending does.

Where we go from here

  1. Fix the original errors (now). Recalculate the base from what successful, efficient districts actually spend on instruction, which means raising it at least 10.75% above the inflation-adjusted base. Move the need weights, including homeless, foster care, migrant and ELL, toward 1.0.
  2. Commission a rigorous cost study in the FY 2028 budget. It should start with the outcome goals New Yorkers want and price the programs and services needed to reach them. It should also account for student needs, competitive regional wages, size, remoteness and sparsity, estimate costs school by school and district by district, and check how efficiently resources are used.
  3. Adopt a new, cost-based formula for FY 2029. It should cover every district, from Montauk to Jamestown to Plattsburgh, and everywhere in between.

I’ve been singing this tune for a while

None of this is new. Here’s the paper trail on this blog, from the Angry Andy years to now.

DatePostWhat it covers
Nov. 24, 2025What’s up with New York State School Finance?The formula doesn’t rationally determine what districts need, has drifted from even its own target, and needs short-term fixes plus a cost-based overhaul.
Apr. 2, 2015Angry Andy’s not so generous state aid deal: A look at the 2015-16 Aid Runs in NYThe state lowered the base again, shrinking funding targets, and large gaps remained for the districts labeled “failing.”
Feb. 27, 2015Angry Andy’s Failing Schools & the Finger of Blame12 of the Governor’s 17 “failing schools” districts were among the 50 with the largest state aid shortfalls.
May 1, 2014The Cuomology of State Aid (or Tales from Lake Flaccid)The state raised outcome standards while lowering the funding target meant to pay for them.
Feb. 7, 2014Friday Finance 101: NY State’s Formula for FailureHow the base × need × region design works, and why raising standards while cutting funding fails.
July 23, 2013Gaming Adequacy by Creating a Veneer of Empirical ValidityHow the successful-districts base was kept low: an 80% proficiency bar, the lower-spending half, and partial instructional spending.
Dec. 14, 2012How Modern School Finance/Education Policy Works: Lessons from New YorkHow the state slipped out from under CFE with a low-ball foundation level and then underfunded it.

The through line hasn’t changed in more than a decade: a successful-schools shortcut, never re-estimated, and then underfunded on top of that. For the national picture, see America’s Best States for Education (2026 Edition), where New York has the largest opportunity gap in the country.

A tribute to Bill Duncombe

Every cost model behind this song stands on the work of William (Bill) Duncombe of Syracuse University and his longtime collaborator, John Yinger. Bill was a professor of public administration and international affairs in the Maxwell School, a senior research associate in Maxwell’s Center for Policy Research, and associate director of its Education Finance and Accountability Program. He died on May 11, 2013, at 57.

Long before CFE was settled, Bill and John were estimating education cost functions with New York State data. Their models measured how much more it costs to reach a given level of student outcomes in districts with more poverty, more English learners, higher wages or smaller enrollments, and they showed how to build those costs into a state aid formula. In 1997 they asked why it was so hard to help central city schools. In 2000 they showed that raising efficiency to the best-practice level would not bring New York’s large city districts even up to a minimal performance standard. In 2003 and 2004, with Anna Lukemeyer, they laid out how to calculate the cost of a sound basic education for New York City and the rest of the state. That was the road not taken in 2007, when the state chose the successful-schools shortcut instead.

Bill and John set the stage for all of the work I do now with Jesse Levin, Drew Atchison and our colleagues: school- and district-level cost models, built to evaluate whether state finance systems give every child an equal opportunity to reach common goals. You can see that line of work in our primer on evaluating state school finance systems (2020) and the Framework for Evaluating & Reforming Education Finance Systems (2025). The New York cost models in this brief follow directly from the path Bill and John laid out more than 25 years ago.

Bill was also a devoted teacher. Over 22 years at Maxwell he taught public budgeting and statistics to hundreds of MPA students, and he brought education policy into the MPA curriculum. NASPAA now gives the William Duncombe Excellence in Doctoral Education Award in his name.

I was lucky to learn from him too. In my early career days, Bill was kind and generous with his time and his mentorship, and he taught me much about the nuances of cost modeling. Thank you, Bill, for your kindness and your guidance. This work carries your fingerprints.

Bill Duncombe’s New York cost studies

Receipts and credits

Companion songs: Why Cost Matters and Spendin’ Ain’t the Same as Cost

More songs: School Finance Rock

Video credits: music generated with Suno. Background images from Wikimedia Commons: Lower Manhattan (King of Hearts, CC BY-SA 4.0); Empire State Plaza, Albany (Edmund Rozell, CC0); Walkway Over the Hudson (Juliancolton, public domain); Plattsburgh Bay (Daniel Case, CC BY-SA 3.0); Montauk Point Lighthouse (NearEMPTiness, CC BY-SA 4.0); Montauk Point Light (U.S. Coast Guard, public domain); Seneca Lake vineyards (Tthaas, CC BY-SA 3.0); Hudson Highlands (Tim1337, CC BY-SA 3.0); Lake Champlain (Annacecchini, CC BY-SA 4.0); Watkins Glen gorge (Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 4.0); Niagara Falls (Rhododendrites, CC BY-SA 4.0); Whiteface Mountain from Lake Placid (Sanford Robinson Gifford, public domain).

Full lyrics: Cost-Based State of Mind (Empire Remix)

[Intro]
Twenty years since oh-seven, and I’ve driven every mile
Plattsburgh in the winter, Montauk in July
Every town I’m rollin’ through, the question’s still the same
What’s it really cost? Not a guess dressed up with a name

[Verse 1]
Yeah. Oh-seven, Albany, the ink was barely dry
Base times need times region, count the kids and multiply
But the base was only teachin’ spend, they cut out special ed
Left the buses and the lights out. What’s the boiler run on, bread?
Took the “successful” districts, then they dropped the pricey half
Averaged what was left and called it “sound.” Come on, do the math
Base is forty percent, the only part with any proof
The other sixty’s multipliers no one tested. That’s the truth
Every spring a price index, whichever one’ll close the deal
Eighty-five hundred for the base in twenty-seven. Is it real?
By their own design it’s ten to thirteen grand a kid
Small cities seven grand behind the formula’s own grid
Poughkeepsie down eleven, and it don’t add, it multiplies
So when they say “fully funded,” show me receipts, not alibis

[Chorus]
Cost-based state of mind (ohhh)
From Montauk up to Plattsburgh, every district down the line
No more guessin’ at the price (no more)
Count the cost for every child
I’m in a cost-based, cost-based state of mind

[Verse 2]
So we ran the cost models, every school across the state
Nineteen through twenty-five, the outcomes and the wage
And the cost of equal chances climbs as poverty grows
Steeper than the spendin’ ever climbed. That’s how the data goes

[Verse 3]
Forty-five of fifty-seven small cities, read the chart
Can’t afford the state average, so they’re losin’ from the start
Raise the bar a little and it’s fifty-six of fifty-seven
Twenty-seven short by fifteen grand. That ain’t a budget, that’s a lesson
Eighty-five cents on the dollar just to land in the middle
Sixty-two to reach for more. Now tell me that’s a little
Utica’s down twenty thousand every kid. That’s a class
That’s a counselor, a nurse, a bus, a band. Don’t let it pass
Point-one-two for kids with no home, kids in foster care
English learners up seven points, and they’re tellin’ us it’s fair
But the model says those weights should be a whole lot bigger, son
So raise the base, raise the weights, and push ’em up toward one

[Bridge]
‘Cause you don’t learn what it takes to lift everybody up
By studyin’ the few who already made it through
A “successful schools” average is no measure at all
Of what it costs to bring success to all of you

[Chorus]
Cost-based state of mind (ohhh)
From Dunkirk down to Newburgh, Niagara Falls to Troy
No more guessin’ at the price (no more)
Count the cost for every girl and boy
I’m in a cost-based, cost-based state of mind

[Tenor sax solo]

[Verse 4]
So here’s the ask: write a cost study in the twenty-eight budget
Start with what we want our kids to know and do, then fund it
Count the needs, the wages, sparsity, how far the bus line runs
Price it school by school, and district by district, every one
Build a brand-new formula for twenty-nine, no hacks
No deal at three a.m., no index pulled out of a hat
Elmira, Ogdensburg, Mount Vernon, Kingston, Gloversville
Salamanca, Jamestown, Utica. We’re keepin’ it real

[Final Chorus]
Cost-based state of mind (ohhh)
Yonkers up to Buffalo, Syracuse to Rochester and the Finger Lakes
No more guessin’ at the price (no more)
Count the cost, whatever it takes
I’m in a cost-based, cost-based state of mind

[Outro]
Montauk to Jamestown
To Plattsburgh
And everywhere in between
Foundation Aid at twenty
Time to build it right

Full lyrics: Cost-Based State of Mind (Piano Ballad)

[Verse 1]
Back in oh-seven, up in Albany,
They wrote a promise for the children of the Empire State:
Take a base, then multiply by need, by region, by the count,
And every district gets enough to educate.
But they built that base on teachin’ dollars only,
Special ed subtracted, and the buses and the lights ignored,
Then they found the “successful” districts, kept the cheaper half,
Called the average “sound,” and filed it in a drawer.

[Verse 2]
Now that base is only forty percent of the money,
The other sixty’s multipliers nobody ever tried to test.
And every spring they grab a price index,
Whichever one gets the budget closed. Never mind the rest.
Eighty-five hundred is the base for twenty-seven,
By its own design it oughta be ten to thirteen grand.
Seven thousand short a kid in the small cities,
Poughkeepsie’s down eleven, and it multiplies, you understand.

[Chorus]
I’ve been from Plattsburgh down to Montauk,
Salamanca to the Sound, every mile of the Thruway line,
And no index picked in April’s gonna tell you what it costs.
I’m in a cost-based state of mind.

[Verse 3]
So we ran the cost models, every school across the state,
Spendin’, outcomes, poverty and wages, nineteen through twenty-five,
And the cost of equal chances climbs with poverty
A whole lot steeper than the spendin’ line, the hill they’ll never drive.
Forty-five of fifty-seven small cities
Can’t afford to reach the state’s own average line.
Eighty-five cents on the dollar just for average,
Sixty-two to reach for more. And Utica’s twenty thousand behind.

[Pre-Chorus]
‘Cause you don’t learn what it takes to bring everybody up
By lookin’ at the few who already made it through.
A “successful schools” average is no measure at all
Of what it costs to bring success to all of you.

[Chorus]
I’ve been from Dunkirk down to Newburgh,
Elmira, Ogdensburg, Niagara Falls to Troy,
Mount Vernon, Kingston, Gloversville, I’ve seen the gap get wide.
I’m in a cost-based state of mind.

[Tenor sax solo]

[Bridge]
Point-one-two for the kids with no home, for the kids in foster care,
Seven points more for English learners, and they tell us that it’s fair.
But the model says those weights oughta be a whole lot bigger.
So raise the base, raise the weights, move ’em on toward one.
That’s the patch to fix the old mistakes,
But the real work’s just begun.

[Verse 4]
So write a cost study in the twenty-eight budget,
Start by askin’ what we want our kids to know and do.
Count the needs, the wages, the size, how far the bus line runs,
And build a brand-new formula for twenty-nine that’s true.
No more guessin’ at the base, no deal cut late at night,
No average of the lucky ones dressed up as what it takes.
Just the evidence, the outcomes, and the cost for every child,
In every school, in every town, for everybody’s sake.

[Final Chorus]
From Montauk to Jamestown to Plattsburgh,
Yonkers up to Buffalo, Syracuse to Rochester and the Finger Lakes,
Twenty years is long enough to run on someone’s guess.
I’m in a cost-based state of mind.

[Outro]
Montauk to Jamestown… to Plattsburgh… and everywhere in between.
Foundation Aid at twenty. Time to build it right.

Leave a Reply